|
Grade C
People tend to be afraid of nuclear power.
They associate it with atomic bombs and various high-profile accidents.
The worst of these was, undoubtedly, at
Chernobyl in the Republic of Ukraine, on Saturday, 26th April 1986.
An unauthorised experiment took place in which scientists wanted to see
what would happen in a worst case failure.
They found out.
The reactor overheated to the point where water
split into hydrogen and oxygen. The two gases rapidly accumulated
at the top of the reactor vessel and recombined in a thunderclap
explosion which blew the lid off the reactor and threw the vessel on its
side. All sorts of nasty muck spilled out of the reactor.
The building it was in was wrecked and as a result of the graphite
moderator catching fire, a plume of radioactive material drifted over
much of Europe, including the UK. Although 9 tonnes of
material spread over much of Europe suggests it was spread pretty
thinly, a significant increase in radioactivity was detected.
It must be emphasised that the disaster was due to
a chemical explosion, not a nuclear explosion.

The Soviet authorities initially claimed that the
explosion was at a cement works, but nobody was convinced. In the
end, they called for international assistance, which led to the USSR
opening up much more. Eventually the Soviet Union fell apart, and
communism was abandoned. It can all be traced back to this
disaster.
Despite this, the nuclear industry is
remarkably safe, because it is governed by very strict procedures.
And a nuclear power station gives off no greenhouse gases or acid rain.
The lists below sum up the arguments for and against nuclear power.
FOR:
- Fossil fuels will run out. We need
something to give us electricity. Nuclear power fits the bill
- No pollution is given out; nuclear power
stations are clean.
- Alternative energy sources like wind are not
reliable.
- Very little background radiation (0.1 %) is
due to the nuclear industry.
- The technology is safe.
- Risks are much less than other risks in
normal life, e.g. road accidents.
- Amount of waste is very small.
AGAINST:
- Renewable energy has less impact on the
environment.
- No level of radiation is acceptable.
People can contract leukaemia (a blood cancer).
- Radioactive waste is the nastiest muck known
to man. It takes thousands of years for the radioactivity to
reduce.
- 57 people died as the result of the Chernobyl
Accident, and a large area was abandoned.
That said, 3000 people died as a result of Osama
bin Laden's attack on New York's World Trade Center on Tuesday 9th
September 2001.
|